Let’s be honest—choosing something to watch on Netflix with your significant other can feel like a never-ending scroll-fest. One of you wants drama. The other? Comedy. Or maybe you’re stuck in the classic “I don’t care, you pick” loop, and suddenly it’s been 40 minutes... and you’re still watching trailers.

Handpicked list of Netflix shows

But here’s the good news: we’ve got a handpicked list of Netflix shows and movies that real-life couples actually agree on. Yup, these aren’t just critics’ picks or algorithmic guesses—these are battle-tested and couple-approved bingeables that won’t start an argument (well, probably).

💑 1. The Night Agent – Suspense with Just Enough Romance

If one of you loves action and the other leans into love stories, The Night Agent is the perfect middle ground. It’s a high-stakes thriller with twists galore, but there’s a surprisingly sweet romantic arc that develops. Think: 24 meets The Bodyguard, but less yelling.

😂 2. The Upshaws – Relatable, Hilarious, and Heartfelt

This underrated sitcom brings laughs, love, and those “omg that’s us!” moments. Couples love it for how real it gets—without ever getting heavy. If you like Black-ish or The Carmichael Show, this is your vibe.

🧟‍♂️ 3. All of Us Are Dead – Yes, a Zombie Show, but Hear Us Out

Surprisingly emotional. All of Us Are Dead is packed with tension, but it also explores friendship, love, and survival in ways that’ll keep you both glued to the screen. Warning: might cause spontaneous hand-holding.

✨ 4. The Adam Project – Light Sci-Fi That’s Surprisingly Deep

Ryan Reynolds? Time travel? Daddy issues wrapped in adventure? This one hits a sweet spot for couples who want heart with their humor—and something visually fun to watch after dinner.

❤️ 5. Marriage or Mortgage – Eye Rolls Guaranteed (But in a Good Way)

You will both yell at the screen. You will disagree with the couples. And you will have fun. This reality show puts couples in the wild position of choosing between a dream wedding or a dream home. Trust—it sparks some interesting convos.

So… What Should You Watch Tonight?

If your "Continue Watching" section is a graveyard of unfinished shows, it might be time to reboot your queue with something new—and approved by other couples just like you.