Choosing the right surgeon is critical—whether the procedure is life-saving, reconstructive, or elective. The best combine precision, experience, and patient-focused care. Here are five of the highest-rated surgeons in the U.S., known for their skill, innovation, and outstanding outcomes.
1. Dr. Atul Gawande, MD, MPH
Specialty: General & Endocrine Surgery
Location: Boston, MA
Affiliation: Brigham and Women’s Hospital / Harvard Medical School
Why He’s Top-Rated:
Dr. Atul Gawande is not only an acclaimed surgeon but also a thought leader in healthcare innovation. Known for his best-selling books and contributions to surgical safety protocols, he’s helped shape modern medical practice worldwide.
Former advisor to the World Health Organization (WHO)
Advocate for surgical checklists and healthcare reform
Ranked highly for both surgical skill and ethical leadership
2. Dr. Rod J. Rohrich, MD
Specialty: Plastic & Reconstructive Surgery
Location: Dallas, TX
Affiliation: Dallas Plastic Surgery Institute / University of Texas Southwestern
Why He’s Top-Rated:
Renowned globally for his aesthetic surgery expertise, Dr. Rohrich is one of the most published plastic surgeons in the world. He is a frequent educator at global conferences and has contributed to defining best practices in rhinoplasty and facelift procedures.
Named "Best Plastic Surgeon in America" multiple times
Editor-in-Chief of the journal Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery
Exceptional ratings from both peers and patients
3. Dr. Sanjay Gupta, MD
Specialty: Neurosurgery
Location: Atlanta, GA
Affiliation: Emory University Hospital / Grady Memorial Hospital
Why He’s Top-Rated:
While widely known for his role as CNN’s Chief Medical Correspondent, Dr. Gupta is also an active, board-certified neurosurgeon with a reputation for excellence in brain and spine surgery.
Specializes in trauma and minimally invasive brain surgery
Combines medical practice with public education and outreach
Recipient of multiple honors for service and expertise
4. Dr. James Andrews, MD
Specialty: Orthopedic Surgery (Sports Medicine)
Location: Gulf Breeze, FL / Birmingham, AL
Affiliation: Andrews Sports Medicine & Orthopaedic Center
Why He’s Top-Rated:
Dr. Andrews is considered the go-to orthopedic surgeon for elite athletes across all major sports. From NFL quarterbacks to Olympic gold medalists, his surgical precision and rehab protocols have extended the careers of countless athletes.
Pioneer in ligament reconstruction techniques
Co-founder of the American Sports Medicine Institute (ASMI)
Universally respected for skill, ethics, and sports science advancement
5. Dr. Mehmet Oz, MD (Honorable Mention)
Specialty: Cardiothoracic Surgery
Location: New York, NY
Affiliation: Columbia University Medical Center (formerly)
Why He’s Included:
Before becoming a household name through media, Dr. Oz was a highly respected heart surgeon known for minimally invasive cardiac procedures. While his public health role has evolved, his surgical background remains noteworthy.
Pioneered valve and heart transplant techniques
Educator and author in cardiac wellness
Recognized by peers during his surgical career for innovation and leadership
What Sets These Surgeons Apart?
Beyond exceptional technical skill, top-rated surgeons share key attributes:
Consistent patient outcomes and low complication rates
Peer recognition through awards, publications, and board leadership
Innovation, including pioneering new techniques and technologies
Compassionate care, with a focus on personalized treatment
Final Thoughts
Whether you're seeking treatment for a complex condition or planning a major procedure, the quality of your surgeon matters. These top-rated professionals represent the best in their fields—blending expertise, innovation, and a deep commitment to patient care. Always consult with your primary physician, review credentials carefully, and don’t hesitate to seek second opinions when making such an important choice.